Tips to Find the Right Cowboy Boot Fit for Online Shopping

A woman pulling on a pair of cowboy boots. A woman pulling on a pair of cowboy boots.

How to Find the Right Fit for Cowboy Boots When Online Shopping

Shopping for cowboy boots online can be a convenient and exciting experience, but it can also feel challenging if you’re unsure about sizing. Cowboy boots have a unique fit that differs from regular shoes, and choosing the right size is crucial for comfort and long-lasting wear. Whether you’re shopping for your first pair of cowboy boots or adding to your collection, here’s your ultimate guide on how to find the right size cowboy boots online.

Step 1: Understand How Cowboy Boots Should Fit

Before you start shopping, it’s essential to know how cowboy boots are supposed to fit. Here’s a breakdown of key fit points:

  • Snug Heel: The heel should feel snug against your foot with slight heel slip (about ¼ to ½ inch). This is normal, and the boots will settle into place as you wear them.
  • Comfortable Instep: The top of your foot (instep) should feel snug, but not tight. The boot should hug your foot without causing discomfort.
  • Roomy Toe Box: You should have about a thumb’s width of space between your toes and the front of the boot.
  • Footbed Fit: The footbed should be flat and secure. You shouldn’t feel your foot sliding around, but it should move comfortably with each step.

Knowing these key fit points will help you make the best decision when sizing your boots online.

Step 2: Measure Your Feet

Accurate measurements are crucial when shopping for cowboy boots online. Feet change shape over time, so it’s essential to measure them each time you’re buying new boots. Follow these steps:

  1. Length: Stand with your heels against a wall and measure from the wall to the tip of your longest toe.
  2. Width: Measure around the widest part of your foot (usually the ball of the foot).
  3. Arch: Measure the length of your foot arch for a more precise fit. Some boots offer different arch fits, so this is useful when selecting the correct size.

Tip: Measure your feet at the end of the day when they’re at their largest.

Step 3: Use Size Charts and Fit Guides

Most brands, including Justin Boots, provide detailed size charts and fit guides. These charts help you match your foot measurements with the right boot size. If you fall between sizes, it’s usually better to go with the larger size, as boots will naturally loosen with wear. Be sure to check the size chart on each product page for specific guidance.

Here’s what you need to look for:

  • Men’s and Women’s Size Conversion: Keep in mind that sizes may differ between men’s and women’s boots. Women’s boots may be sized a bit smaller than men’s, so check the conversion charts.
  • Width Options: Many cowboy boots come in different widths (such as B for Narrow, D for Medium, and EE for Wide). Be sure to choose the width that matches the measurement of your foot. For help with width sizing, take a look at our boot width chart. 

Step 4: Read Product Descriptions Carefully

Online shopping gives you the chance to check the details of each boot style before purchasing. Look for information about:

  • Sole Construction: Some boots have cushioned footbeds or added arch support for extra comfort.
  • Leather Type: Different leathers (like cowhide, ostrich, and caiman) may feel slightly different when broken in.
  • Heel Type: The height and width of the heel can influence the fit. Cowboy boots with higher heels might fit slightly differently than lower heels.

Step 5: Look for Customer Reviews and Sizing Feedback

One of the best ways to gauge the true fit of a boot style is by checking customer reviews. Customers often provide feedback on:

  • How the boots fit (true to size, run small, run large).
  • How the boots feel after breaking in.
  • Comfort and fit tips that others have found useful.

Don’t hesitate to check multiple reviews to get a broader understanding of how the boots fit.

Step 6: Consider the Return and Exchange Policy

Even with all the right measurements, sometimes boots just don’t fit as expected. That’s why it’s essential to shop from retailers that offer easy returns and exchanges. Before placing your order, double-check the store’s return policy to ensure you can easily exchange your boots for a different size if needed.

Step 7: Look for Extra Sizing Help

If you’re uncertain about which size to choose, don’t hesitate to contact customer service for personalized help.

Step 8: Keep in Mind the Break-In Process

Cowboy boots require a break-in period. Even if you’ve chosen the right size, your boots may feel slightly tight at first, especially around the toe box and instep. As you wear them, the leather will soften and mold to the shape of your foot, creating a perfect fit over time.

Pro Tip: Wear your boots for short periods around the house before taking them out for longer outings.

Picking the right size cowboy boots online doesn’t have to be a guessing game! By following these steps—measuring your feet, using sizing charts, reading reviews, and checking return policies—you’ll be able to find the perfect pair of boots with confidence.

Shop for Your Perfect Fit at Justin Boots

Using these tips, explore our collection of cowboy and cowboy boots made for comfort with every wear and discover how cowboy boots should fit.